The Unravelling of Secrets and Lies

1985 found us moving to a new neighbourhood in Winnipeg and the first neighbours we met, Sandra and Dennis, became good friends. Over the years we learned more about their family and background. Dennis’ history is one that some, who are searching for their biological past, might relate to.

Dennis’ story begins in the spring of 1947 in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada where he was born to Stella Stec. Stella was a 33-year-old single lady who lived in Fort William, Ontario (now known as Thunder Bay). She was pregnant and couldn’t tell anyone, therefore, she arranged to quit work and travel for a six-month holiday to visit her good friend, Lil, who lived in Victoria, British Columbia. Nearing the end of her visit, which was also near the end of her pregnancy, she confessed her situation to Lil. Stella, with Lil accompanying her, travelled to Vancouver to give birth.

Stella wanted this child, but knew she couldn’t raise him at this time. She named him Nestor Stec and had him baptized as Nestor James Stec. Stella contacted the Vancouver Children’s Aid Society to have them help her find a family in Kenora, Ontario who would board Nestor for her until her situation changed. Stella picked Kenora because it was within driving distance from Thunder Bay and she would be able to visit.

25 June 1947 Stella and Nestor arrived in Kenora and Nestor is placed with a foster family, in the adjacent town of Keewatin on June 28th. Stella agreed to pay the monthly costs to foster Nestor. February 1948, Nestor moved to a new foster family in Norman and they started calling him Dennis instead of Nestor. When Dennis was about three he was introduced to the Peloquin family who became his long-term foster family and the only family he would know in his youth.

Dennis talked about the awkward situations he experienced growing up in the small town of Kenora.  One of these was not sharing the same last name as his foster family, Donat and Katie Peloquin and siblings Ron and Maryanne. He was Dennis Stec, not Dennis Peloquin.

Stella would come to visit Dennis and most times she was accompanied by a man named ‘Jack’. Dennis recalls them coming for a visit and taking him out for the day to visit sites and eat in restaurants, which was definitely out of the norm for the Peloquin family. Dennis compares this experience to Stella taking him “down from a shelf, like a toy, and playing with him for the day”. This pattern of life continued as Dennis grew and Dennis adjusted to it, as best he could, all the while feeling disconnected from both his birth mom and his foster family.

As years went by Stella realized her hopes of bringing Dennis to live with her in Thunder Bay could not be realized. She also realized that as Dennis joined the sports teams in Junior High and High School there would be a chance he would play against teams from Thunder Bay. She was fearful her secret would come out so she asked Dennis to change his last name from ‘Stec’ so questions would not be asked. Dennis refused and this was another situation where he would have to lie to keep the secrets hidden.

In 1965, four days after Dennis turned 18, Stella’s friend, Jack, died. Stella relayed the news of his death to Katie, Dennis’ foster mom. Katie, for the first time, asked if Jack was Dennis’ dad and Stella confirmed to her that Jack was Dennis’ father. The story of Stella and Jack was finally told.

In 1932, when Stella was 18 she was crossing the Jackknife Bridge to Mission Island in Fort William when a man, in a car, stopped and offered her a ride. His name was Jack. He was married with children and was 23 years older than Stella. This meeting was the start of a 33-year love affair between Stella and Jack.

Stella was born in 1914 in Fort William to immigrant parents, Nicholas Stec and Mary Baranoska. She was the fifth of six children born to this couple. Stella grew up and lived her life in Fort William.

Jack was born in 1891 in Sioux City, Iowa to Thomas William McDonald and Mary Victoria Ryan. He was named Charles Christopher McDonald and was the eldest of five children. In 1912 Charles moved to Saskatoon, Saskatchewan and worked for the Saskatchewan Wheat Pool. It was here he met and married Marion Thomson Curror. They moved to Port Arthur, Ontario (now part of Thunder Bay) about 1929. Charles and Marion had three sons: John P, Charles Alexander and Thomas William. Charles remained married to Marion until his death 18 May 1965.

Fast forward to the early 1990’s, we were informed the Stec household was receiving phone calls from a female looking for Dennis. She did not leave a name or contact information for a call back. It took quite a while before she found Dennis at home when she called. Her name was Debbie and we soon found out she was Dennis’ full-blood sister. Debbie was born 15 months after Dennis.  Stella named her Loretta Grace and knew she wouldn’t be able to keep her so she arranged for Debbie to be adopted to a Protestant family in Sarnia, Ontario, a community far from Kenora. Through Debbie’s search for her biological family she connected with family members in Thunder Bay who told her about Dennis. Debbie and Dennis met and embraced each other as siblings. They have many similarities in looks and personalities.

2001 arrived and Dennis asked for my help in tracking down his half-brothers. The only information he had on them was from their father’s obituary. The obituary read, “… three sons: Charles A. of Palos Heights, Ill., John P. of Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, Thomas W. of Saskatoon, Sask; seven grandchildren; one brother, Thomas, and one sister, Mrs. William Phelan, both of New Westminster, one brother, James, in Detroit”. I started building Dennis’ family tree and within a short period of time it grew to almost 200 people. As much as I was able to build his tree back and down a few branches I could not locate any current information about his three half-brothers. I had found some public trees that contained information on many members of Dennis’ paternal family. I reached out to them but received no response. DNA testing for genealogy was new at this time and this was not an option we explored. My searching for Dennis’ family consisted of the tedious reading of documents and exploring and verifying the connections to suggested relatives. I was writing letters to former employers of Jack (Charles), John P, Charles Alexander and Thomas William requesting information and asking them to forward my letters to the individual or their surviving family. These letters provided no information. I stalled. 

Sample of the correspondence

Meanwhile, Dennis’ son, Ryan, took his father on a journey to relive his past and explore the many facets of secrets and lies that created a tangled web. Ryan filmed this difficult and emotional voyage and produced “Bastard”.

In 2012 I asked for Dennis’ permission to share personal information about his life, and possibly the movie, with Robert, the owner of a public tree, who I felt would have information that would lead us to Dennis’ half-brothers. Dennis gave me permission and I sent an email to Robert providing information about Dennis’ story and why the request for information was made. Robert called me and we talked. He was interested, but I felt he was not willing to commit to sending me the information. I told him about the movie and asked if he would like to see it. He said yes and I immediately sent it. Robert called me first thing the next morning and told me he watched the movie shortly after receiving it. He said he found himself crying and immediately after it finished he went up to his attic to look for all the information he had that would lead Dennis to his half-brothers. Robert sent me this information and I forwarded it to Dennis.

08 October 2012, Dennis nervously dialed the number and spoke to Anne, the widow, of his half-brother, Tom McDonald. According to Dennis they “started a rather clumsy conversation about family searches and genealogy which evolved into a very comfortable, fact filled chat”. In correspondence I received from Dennis he noted “that Anne did not appear overly surprised when I identified myself as Charles’ son but she was vague about any details of my existence. She had heard of Stella through a sympathy card to the family when Charles/Jack died. She had very few details of Stella and was unaware that she lived in Fort William let alone Mission Island. When I mentioned that there were 2 of us, referring to Deb, Ann responded ‘We didn’t know about her’. So I am not clear as to who knew what when but the silence was apparently deafening in both the Stec and the McDonald circles!”.

Dennis relives the secrets as he helps Ryan understand their impact.

In Dennis’ words, “I’ve put my story on the big Screen which I didn’t think was that interesting and which I hid for a long time. Through stories and their telling we give other folks opportunity to listen and license to tell their story which as you know is incredibly important.”

Genealogy and the Importance of Research

As I find a new normalcy from the events over the past year I have decided to revive my genealogy blog. As a genealogist I have learned many important Do’s and Don’tsover the years from a wide range of genealogists. These lessons have caused me to ‘Start Over’ and re-create my tree. 

I started my journey (my husband will say my addiction) as a genealogist at the beginning of 1999 when my sister, Sharon, reached out to me and asked if I would like to work with her and continue the genealogy our parents started. Sharon chose my mother’s side and this left my father’s side for me. The work my parents had accumulated, on their respective family lines, was done prior to the internet when they had to contact individuals or government offices by mail or phone to request information. This search could be very time-consuming as the correspondence went back and forth a few times before the requested information was received.

I, excitedly, took the information my father had accumulated and looked at how I could build on it. The first thing I did was to purchase the desktop version of Family Tree Maker from Broderbund and started inputting the information I knew. Through Family Tree Maker I was led to the internet pages of Genealogy.com which I readily started to use, including MyGenealogy, My Home Pages, Family Tree Maker homepages and GenForum message boards. I created the Shaun and Doug Hobson Family homepage which provided a short synopsis of my family and the information and names I was searching in hopes other genealogists would reach out with information.

On 20 February 1999 I created four posts on the Iceland GenForum message board. The four posts documented the information I knew about the four couples who were my eight paternal 2x great-grandparents that immigrated from Iceland to Canada. Within a week of these postings I had received information on three of the four couples allowing me to take my ancestral lines back many generations.

I started entering the names of these people in my family tree and it was expanding quickly. I soon uploaded my tree to the Internet to increase the chance that I could connect to relatives and find new individuals and obtain more information about branches of my tree. I searched for records and merged them to the people in my tree. Some of the records and material I found came from the public trees of others and I merged them. My tree grew and soon I had over 8,000 individuals.

Some of the individuals I added to my tree were participants in historical events, legendary Viking kings, mythical gods, and even minor King of Ireland, that has an associated record, that took me back to Adam and Eve.

My first thought was this is easy, my research is done! Was it done? No, not by a long shot! 

I wish my learning and understanding of the standards of genealogy equaled the growth of my family tree. However, that was not the case and by the time I recognized I had not properly researched every individual I added to my tree and supported these individuals with accurate source records I had too many people in my tree to try and correct. This led me to starting over in 2016. 

I created a new tree starting with me and adding people one by one. As I add a person I attach records to support their existence and connection to my tree. As the public trees of others provides me with records and/or information about a shared individual or new members to add to my tree I take that information with caution. Before I will add the records of others to my tree I need to first confirm the records identify the correct information for the person I have in my tree — there can be more than one individual in the same area with the same name and about the same age.

I, sadly, am no longer surprised with the number of public trees that suggest we share an individual only to look at their tree and find obvious errors in their tree. Sometime they wrongly connected their family to my relative or they connected our shared relative to the wrong family. How can this happen! It can happen easily as I found out myself when I wasn’t following the standards of genealogy.

As I have uploaded my public tree to Ancestry.com this is where I will find suggested hints. I have found that I can frequently get hints to records that are not connected to my relative, but are connected to the wrong individual in the public trees of others. This results in me taking more time to slowly check the records until I find the correct one for my individual. How can this happen! It happens, I believe, because the algorithm Ancestry.com uses to create these suggested hints is based on the number of times a specific hint is attached to an individual. As people believe the hint and attach it to their tree without verifying its accuracy and this is done over and over by many people then it won’t take long for the Ancestry.com algorithm to suggest this inaccurate record matches my individual.

Since I started my ‘Do-Over’ tree I have built it out to about 2400 individuals. My search for records includes internet genealogy sites, such as, Ancestry.com and FamilySearch.org, but it also includes cemeteries, census records, church records, immigration records, land records, newspapers, obituaries, passenger records, vital statistics, war records, and personal documents held by family members, to name a few. Yes, proper research does slow down the building of a family tree, but I believe it is more important to have a correct family tree than a large tree with many inaccuracies. As my profile on Ancestry.com says, “Genealogy without sources is Mythology”.Now to find out if I actually have individuals in my tree who were participants in historical events, legendary Viking kings or mythical gods, and if my line can be correctly documented back to Adam and Eve.